Tag Archives: Football

Could Increases in Safety Measures Make Us Risk Takers?

27 Sep

If you were to stand in the pit lane at Las Vegas Motorspeedway on October 16th, 2011 and ask Dan Wheldon if he felt safe in a car he would tell you yes. However, I’m sure he would also be aware that his life could be at risk, but it wasn’t a fear. That lack of fear allowed Dan to be one of the fastest IndyCar drivers on an oval, winning the Indianapolis 500 twice. It’s also the lack of fear and the increase in feeling safe that causes millions of Americans to drive without a seatbelt, speed, text and drive, and even take risks that they normally wouldn’t. These risks, and the increase in safety measure in everything have led us to this lack of concern.

The SUV

Remember when the Jeep was a super popular car? I do, my mom even owned one for a short time. Do you remember the big issue at the time? Rollover. Jeep’s were very prone to rolling over due to their higher center of gravity. They were top-heavy, and if you went a little to fast around a corner you were bound to tip the thing. How did we overcome this? We drove slower around corners, we were more cautious to our surroundings and tried to not put ourselves in a position to flip. 

But the car manufacturers and government wasn’t ok with just that, they began lowering the weight so that there was a better balance allowing drivers to take corners at faster speeds in an SUV. Has it led to a mass amount of rollovers? No, but it has created a generation of drivers who don’t worry about the rollover issue as much as we did a decade and a half ago. 

They’ve become so safe, in a 2011 CNN article, they said a person driving a 2009 model car was twice as likely to die in an even of a rollover than a person driving a 2009 SUV. Does this mean we drive more cautious than we used to, or does this mean people in cars drive harder? I’m not sure, but becoming more safe will likely cause us to driver harder than before. 

Sports

Sporting leagues, teams, and youth organizations around the world are always looking for ways to make a sport safer. Little League Baseball banned most of the larger negative weighted bats. They increased the size of the protection in the helmets, and began requiring all coaches to wear them on field (even though most still don’t). The NFL has increased padding, began using revolutionary helmets with military technology in them, and have been forced to make rules to protect players. That last part, that’s due to the safety. Players aren’t afraid of getting hurt so they’ll tackle head first, they’ll dive straight into someone with their heads. Bob Costas was on HBO last week talking about how playing football would be safer if they took the helmets away. 

While the number of deaths are low in these sports, the long-term health risks can be extreme. Serious injuries can occur during acceptable play. However, increased rules have led players to playing with less risk and concern for one another. Physical play has become more common in sports like soccer and basketball, sports once known for their finesse. 

Racing

Ask any race car driver, they’ll tell you that there are serious risk involved and that each of them could potentially be killed on the track. That never made them stop racing though. With the improvements in safety it made a lot of them drive even harder. Look at the INDYCAR Series. There had not been a death during a race since 1999. Sure there have been deaths in practice or in testing (Paul Dana and Tony Renna) recently. This gave many of the drivers a feeling that even if they did wreck they would be a little beat up, but they would survive. Many of them drove fast, risky, and often made moves that they shouldn’t have. 

Just Youtube an old IRL race from the early-2000’s. You’ll see flat-out racing with drivers interchanging lanes, blocking, running 3-4 wide all while being a few feet, or inches, away from one another. It was exciting TV and a great product to watch, but the risk it ran was extreme and scary, but the safety was advancing so fast that the drivers got crazier. They wanted to win, it was all about getting the big money. Introductions of the HANS device, the SAFER barrier, and increased front and side collision safety allowed drivers to push the limit even further. As the years went by with fewer deaths and accidents, we began to see drivers with less respect for one another. Winning became even more import due to the lack of sponsorship dollars. Teams were straining to find funding and began dropping like flies. If you wanted to remain in the series, you had to find a way to be faster and better than everyone else, even if that meant pushing the limit too far. 

Over the years the series began to realize it was getting more risky and the dangers were rising. Their response was to have Honda and other engine companies de-stress the engine and allow it to hit max speed at lower RPM’s. They also lowered the amount of horsepower an engine could have. Thus the speeds were lower and doing so was to increase safety  and lower the risk. All this did was create bigger packs where cars couldn’t pass each other and ran closer. Even though the races of the early to mid 2000’s were dangerous and close, the packs were often spread out and ran in 5-6 car packs. We saw in 2010 and 2011 what size packs we could run in, and they sometimes would be 8-10 car packs. 

This all culminated in the season finale at Las Vegas in 2011 when Indy 500 Champion Dan Wheldon was killed in a multi-car accident on lap 13. The race was one of the most dicey I had seen in years, and was the first time I was enjoying an oval race again. But it wasn’t safe, the cars were 2-3 feet apart in speeds in excess of 210 mph. Drivers were switching lines like it was no big deal, and cars were all flat-out. All of this took place because these were the measures in which the INDYCAR Series deemed to be the safest.

Every Day Life

Today everything is safer, they tell us what is healthy for us and what is not. Cars are equipped with state of the art safety features including side-airbags and seats that support head and neck. They have crash ratings that allow the vehicle to absorb the energy of the crash rather than your body. Those safety features have led us to fewer traffic accidents resulting in death. However, people driver harder than they did before. From my experience on the road people are more risky, they have a tendency to cut you off, speed, and often do so in a dangerous manner. In the past year I have avoided countless accidents through pure luck. Between people on their cell phone switching lanes, or people running red lights and stop signs, I have had several close calls. 

I’ve been driving for a decade now, I feel less safe driving today than I did in the past. Not because of the vehicles, but because of the increase in safety. I feel like I could drive 100 and cut corners if I wanted to because my car has a racing suspension. It’s a Mazda, it feels extremely safe in and I could get away with a lot of dumb things and be ok. 

That’s the philosophy a lot of people have. I read an interview at the end of the book SuperFreakonomics. The writers of the book host a podcast in which they had Glenn Beck on. Now I’m not a huge fan of Glenn Beck because I think he mostly blows smoke. However, in this transcript they spoke about him buying a new car. Beck said the car salesperson was telling him how safe the car was and that if he pressed a button he could take corners like a racecar driver and it had a feature that helped prevent rollovers. I don’t remember the entirety of the interview and everything he said, but the just of it was that the increase of safety gave him and a lot of other people this feeling of invincibility.  

What Can Be Done?

For a lot of us safety is the number one concern for us. We have families, or we are planning to, and we want them to be safe in a vehicle. We want our children to be safe in sports, or behind the wheel when they begin to drive. We want to keep guns and weapons out of buildings for our safety. We want everything to be safe so we don’t have to worry, but does not worrying mean we put our guard down and stop having concern for everyone else? 

Sure safety is an amazing thing and is very important, but sometimes the safest idea isn’t really the safest. Maybe the NFL should reduce the helmet safety measures a bit. A few instances of injuries that are severe will teach players to back off so that we don’t hurt ourselves. Racing series need to increase speeds while maintaining the overall car safety. If cars go faster and drivers have to drive the cars, they won’t be so close to each other.

The INDYCAR Series did a fantastic job with that this year. They stopped using dependable tires and made the downforce less of a factor. This forced drivers to drive the car, they couldn’t control it if they stayed flat-out and raced like maniacs. After the death of Wheldon, this was the only way the series could race ovals. The drivers were scared, cautious, and smart about how they raced. 

The same thing goes for everyday cars. Stop telling us how safe they are before we start driving like a bunch of racers. Make the cars safe, but don’t throw it in our face. The increase of safety often gives people the thought of invincibility.

There’s no fix to any of these issues, but if we can take anything away from this is that the increase of safety has allowed us to live more dangerously. We feel safe, we feel like we don’t need to worry that we’re protected. We’ve put our guard down. Some say that we have begun to de-evolve as a species. That’s a whole new discussion, but maybe this has something to do with it. We evolve (if you believe in evolution, I myself do) to survive and become stronger than our fellow humans. If we take that process of figuring out on our own how to survive and keep us safe, we’ll never try to overcome issues, we’ll just be glad we’re safe. 

Advertisements

The NFL Can’t Replace the Replacements

25 Sep

So by now I’m sure you’ve heard of the “Debacle in Seattle”. If you haven’t, then here’s a quick synopsis of what happened. In a last minute heave from Seattle QB Russel Wilson a ball was caught be a Green Bay DB in the endzone. As the Defensive Back fell to the ground Seattle Wide Receiver Golden Tate grabbed the ball. The ruling on the field was a Touchdown, although one referee signaled an interception.

If you haven’t heard of it, I don’t know how. It’s been the only thing on ESPN all day and has had spotlights on all sorts of media outlets. Which brings me to the point, the NFL can’t let these guys go, and they can’t agree to terms with the old refs. Not because the old refs were bad or I believe the NFL is better without them, but because this is the most publicity an organization could ask for. There’s an old saying, “bad publicity is good publicity”. Basically you always have to pay for what little time you get, and most organizations would be dying for this type of publicity.

But This Isn’t Ok

From a coach, player, and fan perspective this sucks. This is the worst feeling to have. You never want a game to be decided by the referee. In any sport you never want to be the officiating to be the main talking point after a game. Look at the INDYCAR Series. Last fall they had a debacle at Loudon when then race steward Brian Barnhart decided to restart as it was raining on an oval. At that time current points leader was sitting in a position to finish in the top 5. However he spun out on the slick track and crashed. At the time he was set to finish a lap down and be out of the points. After the race though the officials decided to overturn the results and return to the lap previous putting him back in the points.

I’m sure many of you Packers fans are hoping for a similar result. However, you won’t be getting it as the NFL released a statement this afternoon saying they support the ruling on the field and will not overturn the call. The final is 14-12 Seahawks win.

Why The NFL Won’t Do Anything

Sorry in advance, but if you’re a major fan of the NFL get used to this. They won’t be changing any calls anytime soon. Nor will they be working to come to terms with the main NFL Officials. The reason is simple, the officiating may tarnish the respect for the game, or the impressions that it gives, but it won’t change the product. The NFL is the only major professional football league, and the market share it possesses is so large that they won’t care to lose a few people. It also won’t reverse the call because they don’t want to give negotiating power to the NFL Officials Union. You admit the replacements messed up, and the original referee’s will use that against the NFL in meetings. With everything going the way it is, I just don’t see the NFL changing anything around anytime soon. I also don’t see the NFL agreeing with the Officials Union anytime soon. If they do, good, but if they don’t then don’t be surprised.

Plus you can’t blame the NFL for not changing it. Outside of missing the Pass Interference call, the Packers purely screwed up. Sure they outplayed Seattle but they also allowed 8 sacks and on a hail-mary the first thing they teach a defender is to “knock the ball down”. If M.D. Jennings swats the ball downward the catch never happens. We shouldn’t even be talking about this right now, but Jennings wanted the spotlight and wanted the pick.

You Think You Can Fix It

Sure you can, the fans are the one group of people who can push the settlement between officials and the NFL. Simple things like making the NFL lose money by not buying jersey’s or memorabilia. Upset the owners by not going to games or buying souvenirs, Trent Dilfer said it this morning on EPSN, he said upsetting the owners by spending less at the stadium or just not going will be a sure fire way to upset the NFL, the owners, and eventually push the two to negotiate with the Officials Union.

If you can’t fix it, get used to this. It’ll be like this for awhile because the NFL has no reason to fix this problem. The publicity is amazing, they won’t stop talking about it, and why would the NFL admit something is wrong and allow the officials to negotiate with this in their favor.

%d bloggers like this: